Why You Should Stop Writing Detailed PRDs Entirely
The PRD Illusion
I remember sitting in an office in Bengaluru, three years ago, staring at a 30-page document. It was a PRD for a new predictive ETA module we were building for a major FMCG client. It had everything: user flows, edge cases, technical constraints, and a projected timeline that looked beautiful in a spreadsheet. We spent two weeks writing it. We spent two months building it. When we finally pushed it to the client, the feedback was simple: 'This doesn't solve our mid-mile congestion problem.' We had built exactly what was documented, and we had built it perfectly. We had also completely missed the point.
The Cost of Certainty
The Product Requirements Document (PRD) is a security blanket. It convinces stakeholders that because we have accounted for every possible failure state on paper, we have somehow mitigated the risk of failure in reality. In the Indian B2B SaaS context, where we manage thousands of live supply chain trips, this is dangerous. Requirements change the moment a driver hits an unexpected check-post or a warehouse faces a labor strike. A static document cannot capture the nuance of a dynamic, chaotic supply chain. Detailed documentation creates a false sense of alignment that falls apart the moment a developer hits a technical roadblock that wasn't foreseen in section 4.2.
Documentation is not the product; it is a tax you pay on your lack of clarity.
The Hypothesis Tracker Approach
At Intugine, we have largely abandoned the formal PRD. We moved to a system I call the Hypothesis Tracker. It is a living document, usually a shared board, that forces us to move from 'what' to 'why' and 'what if'. A good entry in our tracker contains three specific columns:
- The Core Assumption: What are we betting will happen?
- The Minimum Test: What is the smallest piece of code we can push to prove this?
- The Success Metric: What number moves if we are right?
By shifting the focus to a hypothesis, we stop trying to be right and start trying to learn. If we are building a new dispatch algorithm, we don't document the logic. We document the assumption that 'batching orders by regional pin-codes will reduce dead-mileage by 5%.' We then build a basic script to run on historical data. If the data doesn't move, we kill the feature before a single design screen is mocked up.
Speed as a Strategy
There is a fetishization of 'thoroughness' in Indian enterprise software. We equate big documents with big work. But in a competitive landscape, velocity is the only moat that actually holds water. When you replace a 20-page document with a one-page hypothesis, you empower your engineering team to participate in the product discovery process. They are no longer ticket-takers building from a spec; they are partners experimenting on the problem. This cultural shift is difficult, but necessary. It requires engineers to be more product-focused and product managers to be more analytical. When you stop writing requirements, you start building solutions that people actually want to pay for.
When to Ignore This Advice
Look, if you are building an API that handles critical banking infrastructure where every byte must be spec-compliant for regulatory reasons, please, write your PRDs. Documentation has its place in compliance and long-term architectural stability. But for features, for UX, for new growth experiments? The PRD is an anchor dragging your ship down. Kill the document. Start the experiment. Build the thing that works, not the thing that is documented.